Snooping in my mother's closet one day, I stretched up to retrieve one of her purses from the shelf that was above her clothes rod. I opened her handbag, and took in the smell of lipstick and DoubleMint gum. There on the bottom of the bag, hidden by the rumpled tissues, was a collection of small foil-wrapped teeth. So THIS is where the Tooth Fairy stored our teeth. Hey, wait a minute!
That was the first of several experiences that made me doubt the magic of childhood, and I became an investigative reporter, asking questions about the tooth fairy, the Easter Bunny, and, most importantly, the jolly old man in the big red suit.
Could he be real, if the others weren't? Hoping against hope, I went in search of answers. The logistics of these holiday heroes created confusion in my mind. I WANTED to believe in them all, especially Santa, but evidence was mounting that I had been duped.
My mom was in her bedroom, busily sewing a few weeks before Christmas. I was in fourth grade, and my parents were newly divorced. I lay face-down on Mom's bed, propping up my chin in my hands.
"Mom..." I began tentatively.
"Mom..." I began tentatively.
"Yes," she absent-mindedly responded, adjusting the fabric on her sewing machine table.
"Is Santa Claus real? I mean, is he REALLY real?" I asked, hoping he was; knowing he couldn't be.
"Of course, he's real. Santa Claus brings presents to all of the good little girls and boys around the world. If you don't believe in Santa, he won't bring you presents. You want him to bring you presents, don't you?"
Well, of course, I did. I asked several specific questions, trying to catch her in her deception, and she fielded them deftly, but I was still unsatisfied. It was time for a second opinion.
![]() |
| Daddy, Danny, and me |
"Daddy, is Santa Claus REALLY real?"
He cleared his throat, adjusted his glasses, and blinked a few times. "Princess," he began, "the thing you need to understand about Santa Claus is that he represents the spirit of Christmas."
Do you know what my sweet dad did? He told me the truth. And he told it in the most loving way imaginable. Daddy said the CONCEPT of Santa was very real. Santa represented love and giving. Many people, especially parents, want to perpetuate those wonderful traditions, and they keep the spirit of Christmas alive by acting on Santa's behalf. There are many people who are Santa's helpers, so to speak, who do the work of the beloved legend. Mommies and daddies love their children, and want them to enjoy the tradition of Santa, so they buy the presents, and they give them to their little ones. The outward signs of Santa (pillow tummies under cheap red suits, awkward artificial beards, and black boots) are not nearly as important as what is on the inside that represents the spirit of Santa; the giving and loving.
Daddy let me know that it's always a good thing to believe in the spirit of Christmas; we never want that to end. And it was also okay for me to not believe in the North Pole, and a man who traveled around the entire world in one night to stop at every child's house, delivering presents to good girls and boys.
True to form, my dad made me feel good about my questions, and even better about myself.
Santa represents loving and giving, just like my dad.
![]() |
| Dear Old Dad, around 2012. Photo Credit: Natalie Beidler Mayhew |
Daddy let me know that it's always a good thing to believe in the spirit of Christmas; we never want that to end. And it was also okay for me to not believe in the North Pole, and a man who traveled around the entire world in one night to stop at every child's house, delivering presents to good girls and boys.
True to form, my dad made me feel good about my questions, and even better about myself.
Santa represents loving and giving, just like my dad.













































